Ali Smith Discusses Mansfield, Woolf and War

In a piece for The Guardian, Orwell Prize winning author Ali Smith looks at how the first world war forced writers Katherine Mansfield and Virginia Woolf to rip up convention – and asks if today’s conflicts demand a similarly radical response.

“When [Mansfield] read [Woolf’s Night and Day] in Italy where she’d been sent because of her fast-progressing TB, [she] was appalled. [Mansfield] wrote in fury to her husband John Middleton Murry: ‘It is a lie in the soul. The war has never been, that’s what its message is … the novel can’t just leave the war out … I feel it in the profoundest sense that nothing can ever be the same that as artists we are traitors if we feel otherwise … There is a trifling scene in Virginia’s book where a charming young creature in a bright fantastic attitude plays the flute: it positively frightens me …’ She derided its closed-class nature. ‘Its aristocratic ignoring of all that is outside its little circle & its wonder, surprise, incredulity that other people have heard of William Shakespeare.’

“In this review, published in November 1919, she granted Woolf the status of a writer of another age again – this time the past. Is the novel dying, or alive? she began the review. ‘If the novel dies it will be to give way to some new form of expression; if it lives, it must accept the fact of a new world.’”

Original article by Ali Smith, The Guardian, March 26, 2022.

Tags: Guardian (The)  Katherine Mansfield  Virginia Woolf  

Pirate Comedy Deserves Another Season

Pirate Comedy Deserves Another Season

Cancelled after two season, Taika Waititi’s “silly comedy” Our Flag Means Death “deserves one more voyage”, according to Radio Times critic George White. “ was meant to be sacred…