 |

Affirmations of New Zealandness, offers of help, connection, new Heroes and
Aroha.
PROJECT CO-ORDINATOR, LONDON, UK
"Dear NZ Edge. Thank you for your inspiring website. You've
captured the essence of Aotearoa in a very identifiable way. It is moving to
see our country spoken about in such positive terms, both by New Zealanders
and people from other shores. In London, you can find Kiwis in a great
diversity of roles, which I believe reflects our adaptive and innovative
nature. While the exodus overseas gives cause for concern about the 'brain
drain' phenomenon, I would argue that the vast majority of New Zealanders
intend to return home eventually. It may seem overly simplistic to state we
are a nation of travellers because our ancestors all arrived by sea (and
later, by air), but it is a compelling argument all the same. My ancestors
gave up what little they had in a crowded Europe to travel into the unknown
for the promise of a better life. After weeks at sea, they rowed ashore at
Castle Point in the Wairarapa in a winter storm. Upon arrival, they
discovered the land they had been allocated was covered in ancient forest,
which they proceeded to clear laboriously by hand. Every family has a
similar story of travel and arrival, and it has infected our national psyche
at all levels. We travel because we can. I see many Kiwis wearing their
pounamu with pride on the streets of London. I love what New Zealand is
about and I look forward to the day of my return. Aroha, Kate."
RICHARD BEST, KIWI
LAWYER IN FRANKFURT AM MAIN, GERMANY
"What
a superb site! The Brain Drain / Gain campaign appears to have galvanised NZ
spirit at both national and international levels and now we have this
tremendous site in which the positive energy of New Zealanders can be
shared. Some of us, for whatever reason, find ourselves living in foreign
lands both happy with our choice yet missing Godzone and wishing to be a
part of New Zealand's positive evolution. This site gives us a portal for
awareness and contribution. I'm a Kiwi lawyer who, having worked in London
for two years, now finds himself living in Frankfurt, Germany. Kiwis are few
and far between here (indeed I'm yet to catch glimpse of one) so, in
addition to being reminded by the motivated and adventurous Germans around
me of how beautiful New Zealand is, it's great to have this site for a
virtual trip back home. Thanks to the minds behind NZ Edge. Tremendous
vision. Richard Best." rdbest@talk21.com

MANAGEMENT
CONSULTANT, LONDON, UK
"Reading through the mail on this site and checking out the picture
gallery makes me think that NZ Edge has got all we need to get some momentum
going for our own little "cultural revolution". It's a case of
"just do it". This site has a great selection of logos that could
be put forward in a referendum to pick a real NZ flag; a writer from
Berkeley, California has penned the first couple of verses of an anthem that
really feels authentic when you sing it (or a lot more so than the current
one anyway); and a good stamp in the passport of every departing Kiwi will
firmly remind us of where home is every time we flick through the pages to
reminisce. The first politician with mana and energy that picks up the
feeling this site creates, and brings it out into mainstream media has every
chance of riding on a wave of "red socks" public enthusiasm all
the way to a beach of cultural heroism." Anne Williams.
FILM EDITOR/ WRITER, VENICE, USA
"This is a true find and I am
going to add it to the links on my own web site at www.kiwicafe.com. Reading the site had me bursting into tears, both from
pride and in longing. I am a well
travelled kiwi from Wellington. I grew up in Napier then lived in Sydney, New
York and now Venice, California, near the beach. I have been blessed with a
long and successful career with a passionate love for life. I enjoy the kiwi
spirit and can be found hiking/trailrunning in the local mountains with my
dog Kiri as in te Kanawa."
GERALD D CLARK,
INVENTOR/CREATIVE, SOUTH WALES, UK
"Love the idea of a New Zealand register. The ability to network
with other bright minds from NZ would be interesting, especially after too
long a period in the UK where the majority of Brits and Welsh have far too
much baggage for their own good. I Have developed the world's first family
of super large Artificial Islands (250,000 tonnes) which are equipped with
the latest technology applicable to water/power production, treatment etc.
Built in large shipyards and sea-towed globally. First contracts commence
2002. Best Wishes, Gerald Clark. kaiakgdc@yahoo.com
THINKER, AUCKLAND,
NZ
"What could really make NZ stand out? The Maori greeting
"hongi": imagine if instead of a handshake New Zealanders, that's
all New Zealanders, used the hongi to say "how do you do?" I have
some Maori blood, so I understand the delicacies of getting permission from
Maoridom. But what a gift from Maori to the nation and indeed the world.
Stand up and out New Zealand."
FINANCE MANAGER,
BUENOS AIRES, ARGENTINA "There is nothing like being away from New
Zealand to deepen the bonds of love one has. Being away and then going home
makes you realise what a great place we have and what great people we are. I
love the Kiwi attitude and am proud of everything K1. Keep on the edge and
keep challenging everything. Saludos from Buenos Aires."
STUDENT, AMES, IOWA,
USA
"It's good to find an site that is as simulating, informative and proud
as this one. I am a young Kiwi fella studying in the U.S. so as to finish my
Marketing Degree and gain some international perspectives and experiences.
At the moment I am trying to draw in the "American" experience as
a way to further develop my own academic, social and cultural understanding
and awareness of the world that we live in. Sometimes in a relative 'safe'
and 'stable' environment such as NZ we can become narrow minded and unhappy
with our present conditions (which by world standards are high). I have
forced myself to explore the world outside my safe, loving and happy comfort
zone, to see if I can tackle it with the big boys and girls. Some of it of
course I could do without, but much I will bring back home! I am certainly
not part of the 'brain drain', I'm doing my best to contribute to the brain
gain. I'm bringing back positive experiences to share with you all. All I
want you to do is have a positive attitude and an open mind for a change for
the better."
JOHN COXON, QUALITY
ASSURANCE, MARKETING, VICTORIA, AUSTRALIA
"What can I say? I was a regular visitor to NZ Edge prior to moving to
Australia, and now it has become my lifeline, my link back to Aotearoa. Like
a lot of Kiwis before me, I came over here to follow a dream, to do better,
to be better. Like a lot of Kiwis, I have had a dream start, a new love and
a new career. But my culture and my home go with me wherever I go. This
website inspires, the stories and the successes of other Kiwis from all
parts of the globe inspire. Kia ora aotearoa, taku kainga, taku tikanga,
taku pahi, taku muri. John Coxon."
NASHVILLE, USA
"I am a New Zealander born and bred, but I lived in Brisbane for 18
years and now live in Nashville Tennessee. I am married to a wonderful
American. New Zealand is a beautiful country and one day I hope to bring my
husband to meet the great people and see the superb scenery that NZ has to
offer. This site is new to me, having been sent by my brother in NZ. I love
it. Please keep up the great work and keep us Kiwis who live overseas
informed."
OWNER/OPERATOR OF
TOUR COMPANY, NELSON, NZ
"Congratulations on a wonderful site! I am part of the return of the
"brain drain"!! I have recently returned from some rich
experiences overseas. Having gained a global perspective of women's tourism,
I have just set up a package tour business that caters for women: www.southseamermaids.co.nz.
To all New Zealanders overseas: there is an enormous amount of support for
starting small businesses here. Although my income level has dropped (I was
previously working in London), my quality of life is better and I am happy
to have returned. I agree with your comments in the tourism section about
selling our uniqueness, not competing with the beauty of other countries. It
is indeed our people and ideas that are our greatest resource."

IAIN B.MCKAY,
BROADASTING/NZ CONSUL/CONCERT SERIES DIRECTOR, SALT LAKE CITY, UTAH,
USA
"My position as Director of International Broadcast Media at Bonneville
Communications provides worldwide interaction with the broadcasting industry
and helps pay the bills. My role as Honorary New Zealand Consul enables me
to serve my country. As community service Director of the Temple Square
Concert Series I help promote over 300 public concerts a year and,
naturally, this includes many Kiwi's with world class talents."
STRATEGIC MARKETING,
NZ
"There are those who make things happen, those who watch what happens
and those that wondered what happened - thanks for being in the first
category and creating something great that all of us can benefit from. There
is no reason why we can't once again be the best we can be, if more and more
people get the NZ Edge attitude - grab hold of your dreams and make them a
reality."
DAVID GRANDI, WELLINGTON, NZ
"Congratulations on the
tremendous response to your advertising!! Just goes to show that there are
so many New Zealanders out there who are passionate about our country. The
development of a Forum sounds great. Can't wait. Every day in every way, we
as a nation, are getting better and better!! My world will be even better if
we can get another dynamic Mayor in Wellington, who will move this great
city along to an even greater level of success. Thanks to you and Kevin for
your continued dedication to NZEdge. David Grandi."
LONDON UNIVERSITY, LONDON, UK
"Although I am not an ex-pat New
Zealander, I find your country fascinating. I love listening to Kiri Te
Kanawa and the late Inia te Wiata's songs, and that has caused me to read as
much as I can about NZ and by NZ writers, starting with Janet Frame and now
Alan Duff, Keri Hulme and Emily Perkins, so I have absorbed as much of NZ as
I can, being so far away. I'd love to visit one day. Good luck with your
website, it's great!"
ENGLISH TEACHER,
KWANGJU, SOUTH KOREA
"I enjoyed reading your article on the brain drain. As one of the
many Kiwis living abroad I identified with the difficult choice New
Zealanders face - to live at home or not. I lived in London for a year and
now am living in South Korea. I think it comes down to the fact some other
countries can offer more money and a faster pace of life. Saying that, I
can't wait to get back to Aotearoa and breath the fresh air, see the smiling
faces and enjoy the wide open spaces. I am truly blessed to be a New
Zealander."
RETIRED, BUNDABERG,
QLD, AUSTRALIA
"I chose to move to Australia in 1987 as a result of personal
circumstances. I have not regretted my move, and have no desire to return to
New Zealand to live. Having said that, I do not consider I have rejected my
New Zealand background. Rather I have and am continuing to take it to the
world. NZ is a country which has contributed much to the world, yet still
seems to diminish itself with its continual need to play the game of
one-upmanship with the likes of Australia. Why? My only conclusion, from the
outside looking in, is that it - NZ- still feels, as a nation, that it can
only stand tall by putting another down. For God's sake why? New Zealand is
unique. Just as Australia or any other nation is. NZ does not need to strive
to be better than another. It just needs to be itself - unique, different,
special and purposeful."
POTTERY MAKER, BAY OF PLENTY, NZ
"I have been reading material on
the 'Edge', "if youre not on the edge, you are taking up too much
room". Anyway, I'm not sure whether this idea is something you are
interested in or know who might be, but for a while I thought it would be a
good idea for road signs in NZ such as river names, town names, mountain
names, anything else with a 'Maori' name, have an English equivalent beside
it. My thinking is that this would act as a very inclusive iconic and
informative aid for New Zealanders and tourists alike, and would add tremendously
to understanding the history of this country. What do you think? Kelvin
Falconer www.rolling-cloud.eol.co.nz
INVESTMENT BANKER,
CAMBRIDGE, UK
"Many aspects of New Zealand's culture will contribute to its global
success, such as a can-do attitude. A tall-poppy syndrome will not. A
watered-down education system where half-hearted participation is everything
and success is not rewarded, means watered-down talent and less chance of
young men and women going into battle for NZ. More needs to happen at the
secondary school level. New Zealand is tragically short of leaders."
PETER BARRON,
PHARMACIST & ENTREPRENEUR, DUNEDIN, NZ
"Congratulations on setting up this site. I have lived and worked
overseas for nearly a decade and I am proud to be a Kiwi. I love living in
New Zealand and especially the south of the South Island. We need to
appreciate what we have in our people, culture and country. By thinking and
acting outside the square we can help this wonderful country of ours grow in
self-belief. Kia Kaha, Peter Barron." peter.barron@xtra.co.nz
NURSE, RIYADH, SAUDI
ARABIA
"What a great way to feel that connection with "home". I have
lived overseas in several different countries for 16 years but still feel a
great surge of pride for my New Zealand roots. I currently work in a very
multicultural environment and the people I meet say, almost without
exception, "New Zealand, what a wonderful country, I hope to go there
someday". Our warmth, friendliness and easy going attitude are
recognisable New Zealand traits appreciated by many others. Why do we not
build on this and do more to attract the outside world to our little corner
of paradise? The exchange rates are in favour of the visitor and yet we
still don't seem to have a sophisticated tourism industry capable of
catering to their needs. I hope to return to New Zealand again one day but
economically the time is just not right for me. Good luck to all.
Ma'asallama from Riyadh, Saudi Arabia."
R&D - PRIMARY
INDUSTRY, HAMILTON, NZ
"It is pleasing to see NZ in a positive light and "tall
poppies" being lauded. I am continually amazed at the places and roles
that New Zealanders pop up in, and the lead many of them take in the world.
Having been involved in R&D for the past 21 years, I have been
privileged to work with some of the great research minds in this country,
and been involved in world leading technology development. Unfortunately the
pleasure of working in R&D has always been tempered with the problems of
gaining funding and the eventual promotion and marketing of new technology.
I hope that the knowledge economy will improve our record in this area.
Industry needs to take a greater role in research, either directly or with
funding. It also needs to be more visionary - much of research today appears
to me to be for the moment, not for greater and better things in the future.
We need both."

TEMP FUND MANAGEMENT ASSISTANT, LONDON, UK
"As a young New Zealander currently on my
OE in London, I enjoy visiting sites from home. I found this site to be
particularly rewarding, matching as it does my own sense of pride and joy in
coming from New Zealand. Thank you for producing a site which encourages us
to remember our achievements and to constantly reach for more. As a
qualified historian (MA Hons 1st Class, 1998) I could be assumed to be part
of the so-called brain drain. What some people back home forget is that
young people such as myself carry with us on our adventures over here a
strong sense of our roots and a pride in our heritage that we share with
those we meet. Very few of my kiwi friends over here have any intention of
spending the rest of their lives in any country other than New Zealand. We
are indeed a country full of innovation and energy - thank you for sharing
your vision with us. Clementine Fraser."
ULLI WEISSBACH, TV
PRODUCER, AUCKLAND, NZ "Just found your website today. Looks superb
and promises good content. Although I'm not a NZ national, I live in this
country and I like it. I share your concern about the lack of vision and the
ever present 'tall poppy syndrome' in NZ. WE NEED TALL POPPIES! Ulli
Weissbach." weissbach@pacifica.net.nz"
MANAGEMENT
CONSULTANT, SINGAPORE, SINGAPORE
"I love your page and I believe New Zealand as a country needs this.
The papers in Singapore published a speech made by a professor from the
London School of Economics in Auckland with the headline: "New Zealand
in Danger of becoming a Third World Country." According to the
statistics our position in OECD has slipped from third at the top to third
from the bottom. It's sad to see all the talent leaving New Zealand because
they are not getting the support they need from the Government in terms of
leadership, infrastructure and business support."
FULL-TIME FATHER, HAMILTON, NZ
"It seems like mediocrity
strikes once more in New Zealand. The result of the Royal Commissions
Inquiry into Genetic Modification that was made public yesterday afternoon
shows how fearful the leaders of this country are! This is a great
opportunity for New Zealand to define its EDGE. There is no EDGE in mild
legislation in GM, given the fact that the strategy of food and agricultural
giants is to mess up the food system faster than legislators can react.
Where are the leaders of NUCLEAR FREE NZ? We need them now to define our new
EDGE."
STUDENT, OTAGO, NZ
"I am a student at Otago
University, for my Communication Studies paper I am doing an essay on
the following "Social identities are constructed rather than
natural" in relation to nationality. For my Film and Media studies
paper I am gathering resources for the following essay "Is the All
Black's performance of the haka an expression of New Zealand's distinctive
national identity or an act of cultural appropriation?" In response
you must explain your understanding of New Zealand national identity and the
concept of cultural appropriation." Anyway I was wondering if there was
any information that you could send me that may be in some way relevant to
my work, anything would be great. Thank you for you help. Sincerely Jenny_b_@excite.com.
Editor: Check out the NZEdge story
on ta moko (Maori tattoo) for an exploration of similar issues surrounding
Maori culture, national identity and intellectual property.
HEROES FEEDBACK AND SUGGESTIONS:
AUSTIN, TEXAS, USA
"Hello, I just had the pleasure
of reading the excellent piece you have on Sir
Edmund Hillary. He has been a hero of mine since I first read about him
in the late 1950s. I am no longer the adventure-reading child who could
rattle off the names of the twenty tallest peaks in the world, thanks to the
interest that Hillary and Tenzing sparked in me. However, my affections for
this man have not wavered but only deepened in more recent years. His
tireless work in Nepal may not be the stuff that grabs the fancy of every 10
year old, as did his earlier adventures, but these are indeed impressive
pursuits, as your article so well described. My heart is lifted to read once
again of his tireless gift of self. Thank you!" Julie
Kelly, Austin Texas, USA mailto:jfkelly@bbnow.net
FOOTY, LAS VEGAS, USA
"When oh when is the great Peter
Jackson going to get his piece in 'Hot'. I fell in love with this guy as a
scrawny third-former after watching the one and only Bad Taste. He also must
be applauded for steadfastly refusing to work overseas, thus helping to put
the great NZ on the map. Well, most maps."
TOM NEWNHAM, RETIRED,
AUCKLAND, NZ
"An excellent site that deserves to be well-supported. I am delighted
that it is thriving. May I suggest an unsung Kiwi heroine: Kathleen Hall. It
is my personal opinion that there is no other single Kiwi who did more to
save NZ from invasion in WWII. American General "Vinegar" Joe
Stillwell said that the North China theatre was pivotal to the Pacific War,
because there the Chinese 8th Route Army bottled up half a million Japanese
troops for 8 years (1937-45). If that manpower had been available to the
Japanese, especially in 1942, it would surely have tipped the balance in the
South Pacific. Tom Newnham."
(See Kathleen Hall www.nzchinasociety.org.nz)
Editor: For another influential Kiwi in China check out the NZEdge hero
story on Rewi Alley -
the man whose revolutionary "gung ho" co-ops were responsible for the phrase
seeping into the western idiom.
LIMO DRIVER, QUEENSTOWN, NZ
"What took me so long to find
you! As a retired Corporate fellow now driving limo's in Q/town I spent the
winter o/seas in UK & USA. At the Oskosh aircraft museum in Wisconsin
with two wonderful friends from the USA I managed to hold off saying
anything about the Wright Bros replica aircraft until we went to lunch.
Since returning to NZ I was bombarded with questions. Went to the internet
to find 'Richard Pearse' and found you.
The NZ Heroes page is great. For a small country we have more than our share
of 'Hero's'. Many possible additions however may I suggest Col. W G Malone
of Chunuk Bair. Thanks for a great site!!"
SOFTWARE DEVELOPER,
POCKET NZ, RANGIORA, NZ
"Thank you for such an informative and
interesting site. I'd like to bring to your attention a forgotten New
Zealand hero by the name of Frank
Worsley. Worsley was the Captain of the
Endurance on Shackleton's heroic arctic voyage, and his courage and skill as
a navigator was second to none. I am sure his story would inspire others.
Maybe one day he will make your hall of fame."
    
COMPUTER SYSTEMS ARCHITECT, WELLINGTON, NZ
"Great site. Good to see praise
for tall New Zealand poppies. Lets hope we'll grow more! I'd like to suggest
an addition to your heroes list: Leslie J. Comrie was a New Zealander who is
famous in computer history as the founder of the first Computer Bureau - in
London in 1938. See http://hammer.prohosting.com/~penz/computer/
comrie.htm for a brief summary."
CRAIG, WELLINGTON,
NZ
"Your list of New Zealand heroes is impressive, and I would like to add
three more names; Harold Gillies',CBE, FRCS (1882-1960), Archibald McIndoe
M.B, ChB, F.R.C.S (1900-1960), and William Alban Phillips, PhD (1914-1975).
These are three New Zealanders that have left their marks on the world.
Gillies for example is considered the founding father of modern plastic
surgery. Although his specialty was facial plastic and reconstructive
surgery, Gillies' interests included microvascular surgery, and the
reattachment of amputated limbs. His maxim of "never throw away
anything until you are sure you do not require it" is followed in all
fields of plastic surgery to this day. McIndoe was the cousin of Harold
Gillies and was also a pioneering plastic surgeon who worked primarily with
WWII burns victims, particularly fighter pilots. It was McIndoe who made the
connection between the recovery rate of burns victims who had fallen into
the sea and the concept of saline baths for burns victims. Prior to that an
oil solution was used on their burns. Finally, William Alban Phillips' area
of expertise was economics. He is best known for his infamous 'Phillips
Curve' which models a trade-off between inflation and unemployment. You will
not find any modern economic text that does not have a section on the
Phillips Curve. Needless to say, Phillip's model has influenced the economic
policy of countless governments throughout the world, yet few New Zealanders
have ever heard of him."
PHYSIOTHERAPIST,
ENGLEWOOD, COLORADO, USA "I just returned from a MOVE (mobility
opportunities via education) conference in California. MOVE is an innovative
curriculum that gets kids in wheelchairs up and walking in adaptive
equipment. At the conference there were a group of Kiwis from the Sir Keith
Park School in Mangere. This school has now become the first International
MOVE model site. I was excited to see how quickly we Kiwis take a great idea
and go with it. NZ has a very high standard of education and we are very
adaptive too. If you have a special needs child (who can't walk
independently yet) or know of one, please contact this school. Lets get our
kids out of wheelchairs and in to taking part in life".
WORLD
"Dear Sir. A great idea. I am particularly proud of your heroes page -
there are many people I had never heard of. Is Kiri Te Kanawa to be listed? Also, it would be great if you could allow pages to be e-mailed to
non-NZ friends overseas. Some of my friends have no idea that NZers have made
important contributions to the world!"
SALES MANAGER,
WELLINGTON, NZ
"Great concept. Let's do it - it's time we did! Don't forget the
legendary late Bert Munro, from Waikiwi, world motorcycle speed record
holder on his two old but highly modified motorbikes! And he continued this
with passion and determination until in his seventies! Wayne
Buckingham.
TALKBACK
PRODUCER/PRESENTER, AUCKLAND, NZ
"Dear Edge: I appreciate your
"upstream" attitude towards Kiwis and Kiwiland. I consider my Dad
to be an unsung hero of the pioneering entrepreneurial spirit because he and
his mate started what was known as S.P.A.N.Z. (South Pacific Airlines of
N.Z) in direct competition to the then State National Airline N.A.C. I'm
sure you know the history. He is Rex Daniell and his friend is Bob Andersen.
S.P.A.N.Z. recently celebrated their 40th Anniversary with a highly
successful re-run of the old DC3 routes."
TEACHER, PORIRUA,
NZ
"What a fabulous site! It was neat to read more about Alexander Aitken.
I read about him in a school journal many years ago and have not heard any
more about him from any other source. I find it incredible that no-one else
seems to know about such an amazing New Zealander!"
EMERGENCY SERVICES,
TOM PRICE, AUSTRALIA
"I discovered this site by accident. But what a great job you have
done! I enjoyed the Heroes section especially about Richard Pearse and
Bruce McLaren. I would like to see something done on Bill Hamilton." terry.mellor@hi.riotinto.com.au
EARLY CHILDHOOD
EDUCATOR, RADIO COPYWRITER AND MOTHER, WHAKATANE, NZ
"Great place to look up homework things for New Zealand kids! Thanks for
the stuff on Lord Rutherford. I was sick of everyone calling him a British
Physicist when he was born near Nelson!"
WAKE REMEMBERED
"I read your article with
interest, and have known Nancy for more
than twenty years; speaking to her regularly. My own father was a member of
Special Operations Executive (French section), until he was arrested by Hugo
Bleicher of the Abwehr in Paris in 1943. He was later executed on the 29th
March, 1945 with 13 other members of SOE. Kind regards, Nigel
Felangue."
PHOTO LIBRARY, DUNEDIN, NZ
"I have an idea to make a big
splash for NZ: having a big celebration/campaign for the Centenary of
Powered Flight by Richard Pearse. By
eclipsing the centenary celebrations for the Wright Bros by 9 months this
would potentially cause a self publicising media storm. TIME magazine has
written the following "RICHARD PEARSE His neighbors called him
"Mad Pearse," but in March 1903 the reclusive New Zealand farmer
climbed into a monoplane [...] and flew for
about 140 m before crashing into a hedge. It may not have been a sustained
flight, but it was the most successful powered take-off until the Wright
brothers entered the record books in December 1903." Clearly
this could easily be used to spearhead a variety of campaigns for anything
Kiwi, from tourism to products. Cheers, David Wall, David Wall Photo
Library, Corstorphine, Dunedin, New Zealand."
SOFTWARE ENGINEER, LA, USA
"It was with a great deal of disappointment and a degree of shame
that I read your article on John
Money where
he is painted as a "hero". He is far from a hero to me - I say
this both as an expatriate New Zealander and as a human being with enough
common sense to see through his theories. Granted, he has gained a great
deal of fame and respect for his views, and there is no doubting his place
in history as an academic mind. The fact that John Money neither entertains
nor tolerates criticism of his "theories" puts him in the
[dubious] company of such zealots as Sigmund Freud and Karl Marx.
Intellectual honesty should be of paramount importance to a true academic
hero and this is a quality that John Money has never exhibited.
Worse than Dr. Money's lack of intellectual honesty is the fact that you
attempt to defend this man in your follow up article about him. Let me point
out one of the many problematic passages in your article "John Money
Postscript - Show me the Money". You write: "While acknowledging
Money as a revolutionary and influential figure, Colapinto paints a picture
of him as an undertaker of an experiment in psycho-sexual engineering
clearly the villain of the tale. This picture of Money is a little
cartoon-like, but remains one-sided as Money has refused to comment on the
book or the research, citing medical confidentiality laws. Whatever the
truth here, the case is a nebulous one that tests the fringes of
knowledge. What is undoubted is that whatever the success or failure of
single case studies, or whatever side of the ledger that history decides
John Money will fall on, he has made a respected, considerable and pivotal
contribution to one of the modern era's most controversial debates - the
construction of sexual and personal identity."
Much of the "painting" of Money as the villain of the tale comes
from Money's own journals. Self-documented evidence of the case in question
where Money's agenda seriously clouded his analysis of the situation. You
state that the John/Joan case is nebulous compared to the body of work that
Money has produced. Let me remind you that this so-called
"nebulous" case was the lynchpin of most of Money's work both
before and after the case was published. Not only is it responsible in large
part for Money's fame and position, it has also become a part of the
pseudo-science vernacular despite the facts; that the specifics of the case
were initially mis-reported (by Money) and that the subject of the case has
now reverted to his original sexual identity. This is a miscarriage of
science that rivals the myth of macro evolution - the bastardization of
Darwin's theory that is currently thought and regarded as empirical fact
despite the huge body of scientific proof refuting it. You, the editors of this web site are entirely entitled to your opinions. I
would however prefer to see these biases and agendas listed
"up-front" as it were, given that your work seeks to represent all
New Zealanders, me included. I am forced to discount your entire site as a
result of the bias shown in the treatment of John Money, who happens to be a
figure I know a lot about. You are most definitely showing editorial bias
whilst attempting to have your writings appear objective."
JOURNALIST, AUCKLAND, NZ
"I just made a flying visit to your site and it
looks mighty fine. The postscript on Money is an interesting and thoughtful
one."
ANTI-MONETRIST
"I can't believe you would portray John Money as a hero. His most
prominent case (John/Joan) was a failure, a fact he chose to hide form the
public, allowing many children to be butchered. He refuses to comment on the
"As Nature Made Him" book, but he had no problem commenting on it
when things were seemingly going his way. He also advocates NAMBLA and the
eating of feces as an acceptable form of sexual gratification. why don't you
put that on your site?"
FINANCE, AUCKLAND, NZ
"Great update. Clearly a lot of research has gone into this. I
concur that John Money is still a fascinating New Zealander and has
certainly achieved a lot in his lifetime."
WAIHI COLLEGE HERO SUGGESTIONS:
STUDENT, WAIHI, NZ
"Dear NZ EDGE, I think Eric Tindill should be in NZEdge because he was
so famous he is a New Zealand All Black and he was also a New Zealand
cricket player In 1936 tour of England. Eric missed the 1935/36 cricket
season because he was away with the All Blacks on the tour of the Isles and
France but he became a "double All Black" in 1937 when he was
chosen to represent New Zealand against a touring MCC cricket team. Eric
Tindill is a very exclusive group of New Zealand sportsman who have
represented there country in both cricket and rugby. I would like to see him
in the NZ EDGE .com and would like to thank you for your time. Yours
sincerely Mita Snow.
STUDENT, WAIHI, NZ
"Dear Editor, I am writing to inform you of my view on Temuera
Morrison. My name is Sheryn Clarke from Waihi College doing a study on New
Zealand heroes. He is one the biggest heroes ever in New Zealand. Temuera
Morrison, born in 1961, grew up in Rotorua, he attended Western Heights
High School then left to see through his education at Wesley College
Auckland. He has one little boy called James. Temuera Morrison went through
a very tough time, getting hardly any work and living on not much money, but
he never gave up. Tem found fame first as 'Doctor Ropata' on Shortland
Street then he landed the part Jake 'the Musc' Heke in Once Were
Warriors. So many Maori people look
up to his experiences. Time and time again they went to the movies and wept
as the story unfolded. A story so familiar to many that it seemed as if
their own lives were put up on big screen. This movie Once Were Warriors
inspired so many people to change their ways of living they looked at Tem
for the inspiration to get through the hard times. He also returned in the
follow-up film What Became of the Brokenhearted, He did grow up in
it, and he rejected violence and even drinking and destruction of others
lives. No other actor could have done the job any where near as well as
Temuera Morrison."
STUDENT, WAIHI, NZ
"I'm a student from good old Waihi College doing a Liberal studies
task to write a letter to you guys asking for a certain person to be put on
your web site. Personally I found the site quite adequate and educational.
Real country changing heroes that really made a difference like Sir Edmund
Hillary etc. I have a different letter that is a kind of a proposition, idea
type thing. It is extending your site to further it and hopefully better it.
The extension being a place on the site for up and coming heroes to be
recognised and encouraged to strive for what potential they have buried
inside them. I think greater achievements will be reached making New
Zealand. I have up and coming Hero in
mind that may change the way people see N.Z in
the surfing world. His Name is Bobby Hansen, he's young and has heaps of
potential. By putting him on the site I think he will strive even harder and
reach what N.Z has been lacking all these years in surfing. This applies to
all achievers. Please consider this proposition as I think your site will
benefit from it immensely, more visitors, more learning about N.Z greats.
Thanks James Allsopp."
STUDENT, WAIHI, NZ
"Dear New Zealand Edge I have shown some
interest in your site and have noticed that you dont have one of my
heroes Scott Dixon and have found some
basic facts about him and would like it if you could put his information on
your site for future visitors to your site. Thank you. Shan."
STUDENT, WAIHI, NZ
"My name is Harley Fletcher and I am a student at Waihi College I
am doing an assignment for Liberal Studies and part of that assignment is
for me to write to you and suggest someone that is suitable for your web
site. I have chosen Sir Richard Hadlee. Sir
Richard Hadlee is New Zealands best cricket player of all time and I
believe your web site should recognise him as a national hero. He has won
New Zealand sports person of the year 2 times, sports person of the decade
and sports person of the last 25 years. He has been awarded a Knighthood for
his services to cricket, which is an amazing achievement. He had an
outstanding career, a world record 10 wickets in a match 9 times, world
record 5 wickets in a test innings 36 times. He was the first player in test
history to take 400 wickets and had the world record of 431 test wickets
until Kapil Dev from India went beyond. Even though he is no longer playing cricket he still is involved with it. He is
always on hand to help and give advice for New Zealand International
players. He show true characteristics of a hero and I think there is not
many people who deserve to be on you web page more than him. A man who has
been recognised by the queen for his services to cricket should definitely
be recognised by your web page. Yours sincerely Harley Fletcher."
|
 |


We
welcome new friends to the New Zealand Edge who have registered this month from around the world:
Abu Dhabi, UAE
Alsfeld, Germany
Ardrossan, Scotland
Bangalore, India
Bangkok, Thailand
Basingstoke, England
Belle Harbour, New York
Berne, Switzerland
Binan, Laguna, Phillipines
Boston, USA
Brisbane, Australia
Buenos Aires, Argentina
Bulawayo, Zimbabwe
Bundaberg, Australia
Cambridge, UK
Canberra, Australia
Chicago, Illinois
Cleveland, Ohio
Colombo, Sri Lanka
Colorado, USA
Columbia, Missouri
Darmstadt, Germany
Denver, Colorado
Dublin, Ireland
Edmonton, Canada
Frankfurt, Germany
Gothenburg, Sweden
Grand Rapids, Michigan
Holmbury St Mary, England
Hong Kong
Illinois, USA
Iowa, USA
Istanbul, Turkey
Kovor, Palau
Kuwait City, Kuwait
Kwangju, South Korea
Lancaster, Kentucky
Lansing, Michigan
London, England
Langley,BC, Canada
Los Angeles, California
Melbourne, Australia
Metro-Manila, Phillipines
Nashville, USA
New Jersey, USA
New Orleans, Louisiana
New York
Notts, England
Nottingham, England
Ohio, USA
Oslo, Norway
Palo Alto, California
Perth, Australia
Phoenix, Arizona
Redondo Beach, California
Riyadh, Saudi Arabia
Rousee, Bulgaria
Salt Lake City,Utah
San Mateo, California
Seattle, Washington
Seoul, Korea
Singapore
Sonderborg, Denmark
South Wales
Sydney, Australia
Syracuse, New York
Tokyo, Japan
Tom Price, Australia
Toronto, Canada
Utah, USA
Valboune, France
Vancouver, Canada
Victoria BC, Canada
Victoria, Australia
Washington DC
Washington, New Jersey
And from The Edge:
Auckland
Birkenhead
Blenheim
Cambridge
Christchurch
Devonport
Dobson, West Coast
Drury
Dunedin
Edgecumbe
Gisborne
Gore
Hamilton
Havelock North
Invercargill
Katikati
Kawau Island
Lower Hutt
Mangawhai Heads
Manukau City
Masterton
Morrinsville
Mt Maunganui
Napier
Nelson
New Plymouth
North Harbour
Oakura
Opunake
Otaki
Otematata, North Otago
Palmerston North
Paraparaumu
Picton
Plimmerton
Porirua
Queenstown
Rangiora
Rotorua
Ruawai, Northland
Silverstream
Takapuna
Taupo
Tauranga
Te Awamutu
Te Horo
Timaru
Tokoroa
Tutukaka
Wahi
Waikau
Waipukurau
Wanganui
Warkworth
Watakere City
Wellington
Whakatane
Whangarei
STUDENT,
FRANKFURT, GERMANY
"Great site, guys - keep it up! I've been surfing for NZ expat type sites
for a while now and hadn't found anything more in depth than "Buy Marmite
Here!" advertisements."
WOODWIND INSTRUMENT
REPAIRER, AUCKLAND, NZ
"Great site. I'm so proud to be a NZer."
MONEY MARKET TRADER,
SYDNEY, AUSTRALIA
"Love the site and the philosophy behind setting it up. Makes me even
prouder to be a Kiwi. I look forward to coming home for good one day."
(I Love) NZ!
"I noticed a tourist wearing an "I love NZ" t-shirt in the
weekend and I thought: why is it that only tourists think of wearing such
clothing? I think there should be a national I LOVE NZ day where we all wear I
LOVE NZ t-shirts. There could be events all over the country celebrating cool
things about NZ."
Editor: Agreed! In early November NZEdge will be launching an on-line shop
where you will be able to choose from a range of t-shirt designs inspired by
the New Zealand Edge.
RESTAURANT MANAGER,
AUCKLAND, NZ
"Well, what can I say. Finally a place where Kiwis who have faith in
their country can meet, share ideas, and feel good about ourselves. Long live
the "feel good" feeling of being a Kiwi. One can only hope that this
is the start of something BIG."
TEACHER, NZ
"I am a New Zealander by choice. I came from Latin America 35 years ago.
I went back home for the first time last year, and after 20 days back in Latin
America, I could not wait to come back to New Zealand. Upon my return, my
heart cried for sheer joy when I sighted New Zealand from the plane. I would
not live in any other country in the world!"
KATRINA CHUPEIN, MT
HOLLY, NEW JERSEY, USA
"Hi! I would love to hear from anyone from the Picton Blenheim area. I
was born in Picton. (I was called Katrina Bain then). I just heard about NZ
Edge: great to find a good site about New Zealand." kacee44@hotmail.com
RETIRED, MORRINSVILLE,
NZ
"Have just found your site. It's good to see positive things about our
wonderful country. We have so much to be proud of and be grateful for but it
seems that the pessimists are running the media and that many of us have been
successfully brainwashed."
PAULI MONTES, CATERING
SUPERVISOR, CHICAGO, ILLINOIS, USA
"I have been away from home since 1985. It would be nice to stay in touch
with what is happening in my homeland. I am Maori and I seek other Maori to
correspond with in the United States, specifically in the Chicago area."
paulimontes@hotmail.com
INSURANCE, LONDON, UK
"Really great site, makes me very
homesick."
TEACHER, COACH, SOUTH
POINT, OHIO, USA
"I have visited NZ 3 times in the last 2 years and have just fallen in
love with the country and the people. I now consider it my home away from
home. I want to keep up with everything that is going on there and find out
any way I can be of service to this great country."
EXECUTIVE SEARCH, HONG KONG
"I am impressed by the NZ Edge
site. As a Kiwi who has lived in and out of NZ for the past 20 years I am very
much aware of the impact the NZ has on the rest of the world. Being in
executive search it is statistically surprising how often I come across Kiwi's
in senior roles around the world. Best success for the future and let's hope
the AB's will be bringing some silverware home on Saturday."

QUALITY MANAGER,
AUCKLAND, NZ
"This web site was recommended during a recent conference. I am
interested in improving NZers perceptions of ourselves. We can share in
others' glory and use it to motivate ourselves, without putting people
down."
AUCKLAND, NZ
"What an excellent way of telling the world about this country. I will
make sure my daughter in Spain learns about this site."
SYDNEY, AUSTRALIA
"Love
NZ Edge to bits! Living in Australia despite the close proximity, often feels
very far away, mainly due to the lack of news and information on the standard
media, I must admit I get very nostalgic over the Air NZ Ads!! Thanks to you
and your team for the site it makes all the difference, keep up the good work.
Kind regards, Vanessa Cruthers"
SHAREBROKER, TAURANGA,
NZ "Well done. It's all about changing the culture. Prior to 1987 we
believed in ourselves, and many of our business "tall poppies" let
us down. It is time to get over it, and I commend you for making a
start.
PRESIDENT, EDMONTON, ALBERTA, CANADA
"Great Find!"
VENTURE CAPITAL, WELLINGTON. NZ
"Congratulations on the site. If
anyone is interested in the VC world in New Zealand please feel free to be in
contact on grant.uridge@igrow.co.nz
Grant Uridge, I Grow Private Equity."
BARRY DOWELL, DIRECTOR, CHRISTCHURCH, NZ
"Food for the Soul. NZ needs to celebrate its people and achievements,
this site is excellent. Barry Dowell."
WINERY MARKETING MANAGER, BLENHEIM, NZ
"I've
been thinking...was impressed with your communication in the Sunday Times and
have only just found the time to follow up, my neck is cricked from reading
everything and I need to digest how I fit in to this but somehow I will thanks
for the wake up call, very timely."
FINANCE CONSULTANT,
REMUERA, AUCKLAND, NZ
"A great site for the promotion of New Zealanders everywhere. I shall be
broadcasting this to all my overseas friends and relations!"
PROJECT MANAGER, LONDON, UK
"Hi - I am a Kiwi living in London
who is passionate about everything New Zealand! Have just had this site
recommended to me. Love the design, layout and hot info. Looking forward to
getting my regular fix of what's going down in Aotearoa and what Kiwis are up
to globally! Cheers."
UK
"Love the site and it helps me feel great to be from New Zealand.
The other weekend we went to a taste New Zealand day out in Richmond - it was
great to see - bright faces with an attitude that makes you feel that we come
from somewhere special. I think you can spend too much time in England - it's
great yet it does get to you after a while."
COMPANY DIRECTOR,
CHRISTCHURCH, NZ
"Excellent idea to help NZ benefit from our people. We have a great
range of ideas and experience spread worldwide. Let's tap into it! I am very
keen to get email updates, and be actively involved. Also keen to get
details so I can network with Kiwis offshore to grow my international
investment business from NZ.
MANAGER, CHRISTCHURCH, NZ
"Check out www.foragefood.com
for Kiwi initiative."
CORPORATE COMMUNICATIONS, LONDON, UK
"Fantastic! love the concept.
Never knew there were so many famous and influential kiwis!!! Best
wishes all, Reuben Aitchison raitchison@heathlambert.com"
MILITANT CARNIVORE,
WELLINGTON, NZ
"Great site. Give us more. Is this evolution or revolution?"
MANAGING DIRECTOR, AUCKLAND, NZ
"Great
site, well needed positive angle to the NZ mentality. Keep it up."
TEACHER, AUCKLAND, NZ
"A great idea. We need to know
what it is that makes us what we are - people who have an edge and live on the
edge . Looking forward to enjoying the site."
CONSULTANT, MT
MAUNGANUI, NZ
"I have a passion to be part of the rekindling of
national pride; the bringing together of the hearts and minds of all our
people, at home and beyond our shores. Through restoring dignity, NZ can truly
be at the leading edge. Thank you NZ Edge for reaching out globally to
acknowledge success and embrace our Kiwi identity." jen.active@xtra.co.nz
PURCHASE MANAGER, UAE
"I'm excited since the day my
application was approved for immigration to New Zealand, and.... am eager to
get down-under there, to routinely breathe virgin fresh air, help make life
fun and adventure,... that's my tiny Kiwi prayer. I guess that this intention
is obviously fair when you've lived long under harsh desert care...from the
melting sands of U.A.E.
MARKETING DIRECTOR, AUCKLAND, NZ
"Very happy to be part of the
Network"
WRITER, AUCKLAND, NZ
"I've just discovered your site
after seeing today's Sunday Star Times. Well done!"
RETIRED EDUCATOR, AUCKLAND, NZ
"Drawn
in by the full page advertisement in the Sunday Star Times August 12th. Love
the key words optimism, energy and motivation. Have given this site to my
grown-up children too."
CREATIVE WRITING COURSE
COORDINATOR, WELLINGTON, NZ "This is fantastic. Look forward to
profiles of artists and writers. A great resource for the young and old."
COMPUTER SYSTEMS
ARCHITECT, WELLINGTON, NZ
"Great site. Good to see praise for tall New Zealand poppies. Let's hope
we'll grow more!"
TEACHER, AUCKLAND, NZ
"I am New Zealander by choice. I
came from Latin America 35 years ago. I went back home for the first time last
year, and after 20 days back in Latin America, I could not wait to come back
to New Zealand. Upon my return, my heart cried of sheer joy when I sighted New
Zealand from the plane. I would not live in any other Country in this
world." Jorge Figueroa
LEADING WRITER,
ARDROSSAN, SCOTLAND
"It is good to see a well designed informative site, that shows New
Zealand off to good effect."
COMMUNICATION
EXECUTIVE, HAMILTON, NZ
"Very impressive site - fast, interesting, stuffed full of information
without looking OTT."
GENERAL MANAGER,
CANBERRA, AUSTRALIA
"Kia ora Your site has just been referred to me. What a fantastic
concept. Keep up the good work. He kone ra"
MELBOURNE, AUSTRALIA
"I am actually a NZer living in Melbourne. I think the whole concept of
the New Zealand Edge is great. The page has a great impact with so much to read
and check out. Thanks. Judy Reid"
RETIRED EDUCATOR,
AUCKLAND, NZ
"Drawn in by the full page advertisement in the Sunday Star Times August
12th. Love the key words: optimism, energy and motivation. Have given this
site to my grown-up children too. Looking forward to enjoying this site."
RETAIL MANAGER,
PORIRUA, NZ "Your site seems very interesting. I am interested mainly
for my own and friends/family motivational purposes. Thanks for such a great
positive initiative."
OPERATIONS, DUBLIN,
IRELAND
"Inspiring."
COMPUTER CONSULTANT,
OAKURA, NZ
"I saw your ad in the Sunday Star Times and have found your site
intriguing. I will recommend it to a number of people in NZ and
overseas."
TEACHER, OPUNAKE,
NZ
"Wow - what a positive site! Inspiring for our kids. Thanks."
ONLINE AIR EXPRESS
OPERATOR, AUCKLAND, NZ
"Brilliant and inspirational!"
DAVID WEUSTEN,
FINANCIAL CONSULTANT, CHRISTCHURCH, NZ
"I would like to support NZ
Edge's initiative and offer my services to help Kiwis around the world. To see
what I can offer, check my web site: www.fspnz.com.
David Weusten"
CEO, SYDNEY,
AUSTRALIA
"Great site - I am already recommending it!"
IT CONTRACTOR, LONDON,
UK
"A showcase of things that show we have right to be proud of those who
choose to be labelled Kiwis."
COMPANY DIRECTOR, NEW PLYMOUTH, NZ
"I
like your vision of a future pathway for the good of all New Zealanders. I
feel a need to join in on this journey and will welcome continued
information."
NZ
"This country is in trouble and I applaud any effort to improve
things!"
DIRECTOR, AUCKLAND,
NZ
"A very dynamic site."
WAITAKERE CITY, NZ
"Great site. I publish a Rotary club magazine for which the site is
great"
EDMONTON, CANADA
"I am in Canada for 12 months with a working holiday visa. I was stoked
to hear about this site so that I can keep in touch with the country I'll
always call home!"
NZ
"Excellent site, keep up the good work!"
FLOORING INSTALLATION,
AUCKLAND, NZ
"Just found the web page and really like the concept. Look forward to
visiting frequently!"
REVENUE AGENT, SHORELINE, WA, USA
"I
have just learned about this website, and although I am now a US citizen I
still like to keep up on events in my native country."
WORLD
"Dear Sir / Madam: Thank you for such an informative site. Its nice to
see someone lifting up excellence and highlighting it rather than seeing the
'tall poppy' syndrome. Well done and keep it up. Regards Mark Liddle."


|

|